Lawsuit challenges Staten Island's City of Yes initiative

A group of Staten Island officials and residents have filed a lawsuit against New York City's "City of Yes" zoning initiative. They argue that the city did not properly assess environmental impacts before the plan was approved, which could affect housing and battery storage projects across the borough. The lawsuit specifically targets the housing opportunity part of the initiative, which aims to create 80,000 new housing units over the next 15 years. Critics, including Councilmember David Carr, believe the housing estimate is underestimated and that the environmental review was inadequate. City Hall defended the initiative, highlighting its potential to address the housing crisis and improve neighborhoods. A spokesperson stated that they would respond to the lawsuit, emphasizing their commitment to a transparent review process. The lawsuit is supported by several civic groups and local politicians. The plaintiffs chose Staten Island for the legal action, expecting to find a sympathetic judge and hoping to highlight the significant impact the plan could have on the borough.