Underwood's actions after Roberts' win sparked controversy

"American Idol" judge Carrie Underwood faced criticism for her reaction to Jamal Roberts' victory and later named her new baby goat after him. Roberts, a 27-year-old, won Season 23, while Underwood was seen sitting down as he began his winner's performance, sparking accusations of disrespect. Fans pointed to her perceived lack of support throughout the season, leading to backlash online. Underwood congratulated Roberts on social media, but many viewers saw it as insincere. She then named a goat Jamal, which further fueled the controversy, though she has not directly addressed the criticism.