New study debunks 50-year-old theory that essential genes mutate less
A new study challenges a 50-year-old evolutionary theory, finding no evidence that essential genes mutate less frequently than others. Researchers say earlier support may have been an illusion caused by harmful mutations being eliminated by natural selection before detection. Published in PLOS Biology, the University of Bath team analyzed the largest collection of spontaneous mutations in E. coli and baker's yeast. Using mutation accumulation experiments to minimize selection bias, they found no relationship between gene importance and mutation rates in either species, contradicting the protective mutation hypothesis. The findings support the conventional model where mutation and natural selection act separately. While mutation rates vary across genomes due to DNA replication timing, the researchers found no grounds for a paradigm shift, concluding the protective theory was "a triumph of hype over substance."