Football Manager star system faces scrutiny over player ratings accuracy
The Football Manager Star System is being questioned for its accuracy in assessing player abilities. Players with similar skills can have different star ratings, leading to confusion among managers. This inconsistency raises concerns about the system's reliability. Recent findings show that potential ability ratings are also misleading. For example, a highly-rated youth prospect may not reach the expected level, while a lower-rated player could outperform them. This suggests that star ratings are influenced by various factors and should not be solely relied upon. Players are advised to focus on individual attributes and scout reports rather than star ratings. Understanding a player's skills and intangibles can lead to better team performance. The complexities of the game add to its challenge and enjoyment.